Osho's perspective on Criticism
When Osho Spoke About Criticism
Passages from the discourses where this theme comes alive.
Osho, dr. Abraham kovoor has attacked you in an article published by the weekly current. What do you have to say about it?
He says, "I am an atheist because I do not believe in Gods, and I do not believe in Gods because it is not rational to believe something for which there is no objective evidence." There is no objective evidence for the subjectivity. That's why we call it "subjectivity." By the very nature of it there is no objective evidence, but inference is possible. A candle is a candle. A candle is not Kovoor. And there IS a difference! And it is not a slight difference. The difference is great because the difference is that of subjectivity. The candle has no subjectivity; it has no interiority. The candle has no intention. It is burning there; it has no innermost core. If Kovoor is standing there, he has an intention, an interiority. That interiority, that intention, that subjectivity cannot be objectified, and if we cannot objectify a single man's consciousness, how…
Question: OSHO, WHY DO PEOPLE CRITICIZE YOU AS A SELF-STYLED AND SELF-APPOINTED GOD? There are many things to be understood. It is one of the ancientmost reactions of people, it is not anything new. It happened with Krishna, with Moses, with Christ, with Mahavira, with Buddha, with Mohammed, with Al-Hillaj Mansur. It has been happening all along, as far back as one can see. People live in misery and they cannot accept anybody who is not miserable just like themselves. To accept that somebody has become blissful is humiliating to them; it wounds their ego. They would like a Jesus, a Buddha, a Krishna, not to be at all, because the height of that Everest suddenly makes them aware of where they are. It is said that camels don't want to go near mountains, they are very much against mountains.
Their second question is: as a religious leader, you are above human hurts, but do you criticize america and christianity so much because you feel hurt?
They arrested me without any arrest warrant, and without showing me any reason for arresting me. Just a piece of paper on which there were a few names -- "We have been ordered from above that these people should be immediately arrested." I said, "But you should look at our passports! My name is not on this paper; neither are the names of the six people who are with me on this paper. You are absolutely absurd. Just look at our passports and compare with your names; you are arresting the wrong people." Still, we were arrested. In fact, they had no evidence at all to arrest me. But they did not give me bail for twelve days. They arrested me in North Carolina, and the flight from North Carolina to Oregon, where the commune was located, was only five hours. It took twelve days for me to reach Portland,…
Osho, if two true masters criticize and condemn each other, what should the disciples understand?
If you are a disciple, you will choose what resonates with your heart and move on. You will not bother about who criticized whom. Nor will you oppose the one who criticized. Who are you to judge! A disciple, and he decides who is a true master and who is not? The very idea is foolishness. It is like a blind man deciding who can see and who cannot. How will the blind judge who sees? The blind need only know: “I cannot see.” Having found a friend, take his hand and walk. Then, through your own experience, see: walking with this person, do I fall into pits? Walking with him, do I keep bumping into things? Walking with him, do I end up breaking my hands and feet? If your experience shows otherwise, then to think, “This man must have eyes,” is at first only an inference. But that…
ओशो, यदि दो सदगुरु एक-दूसरे की निंदा और आलोचना करें तो शिष्यों को क्या समझना चाहिए?
यदि तुम शिष्य हो तो तुम जो तुम्हारे हृदय से मेल खा जाये उसे चुन लोगे और चल पड़ोगे। तुम इसकी फिर चिंता ही न करोगे कि किसने आलोचना की। तुम फिर जिसने आलोचना की है उसका विरोध भी न करोगे। तुम हो कौन निर्णय करनेवाले! शिष्य और निर्णय करे कि कौन सदगुरु है, कौन सदगुरु नहीं है? बात ही मूढ़ता की है। यह तो अंधा निर्णय करने लगा कि किसको दिखाई पड़ता और किसको नहीं दिखाई पड़ता। अंधा कैसे निर्णय करेगा, किसको दिखाई पड़ता है, किसको नहीं दिखाई पड़ता? अंधे को इतना ही जानना चाहिए कि मुझे दिखाई नहीं पड़ता। अब मुझे जिससे दोस्ती बन गई हो, उसका हाथ पकड़कर चल जाना चाहिए। और अपने अनुभव से देख लेना चाहिए कि इस आदमी के साथ चलने से गड्ढों में गिरना तो नहीं होता? इस आदमी के साथ चलने से रास्ते पर टकराहट तो नहीं होती? इस आदमी के साथ चलने से हाथ-पैर तो नहीं टूटते?
Can we disagree or criticize?
definitionProfound Quotes on Criticism
Explore our structured collection of meaning-mapped quotes regarding Criticism.