Ask Osho!
Osho on Will the Western mind have to expand as the Eastern mind has?

Will the Western mind have to expand as the Eastern mind has?

True growth lies in the integration of the rational and the receptive, where science embraces logic and religion surrenders to the divine.

— Osho
According to Osho, the 'Western mind' need not expand like the 'Eastern'; they are complementary modes, not geographies. For science, the Western (rational, Aristotelian) mode excels; for religion, one must shift into the Eastern (non-rational, receptive) mode. Whenever true religion appears in the West, its quality is Eastern. Genuine growth means integrating both polarities—using logic for science and surrendering into meditative receptivity for the divine.

Use your head for science, but to touch the sacred you must quiet the head and open the heart; real wisdom blends both.

In His Own Words

From the Discourses

Passages where Osho speaks to this question — each links to the complete discourse.

So organized religions are a curtain to us. They will have to go in order for us to see the sky.

Yes. They cover the window, they are obstacles. WILL THE WESTERN MIND HAVE TO EXPAND AS THE EASTERN MIND HAS? The Western mind can succeed as far as science is concerned, but it cannot succeed in religious consciousness. Whenever a religious mind is born, even in the West, it is Eastern. In Eckhart, in Boehme, the very quality of the mind is Eastern. And whenever a scientific mind is born in the East, it is bound to be Western. East and West are not geographical. West means the Aristotelian, and East means the non-Aristotelian. West means equilibrium, and East means no equilibrium. West means the rational and East means the irrational. Tertullian was one of the most Eastern minds in the West. He said, "I believe in God because it is impossible to believe. I believe in God because it is absurd." This is the basic Eastern attitude: because it…
Read the full discourse →

Beloved master, the western mind is so oriented toward analysis, the left hemisphere of the brain -- the eastern mind just the opposite, the intuitive right hemisphere. The west is fascinated by the east and the east by the west. Equal amounts of both -- is this the harmony of wisdom and the transcendence of opposites?

Prem Dhanesh, the transcendence of opposites is not a quantitative phenomenon, it is a qualitative revolution. It is not a question of equal amounts of both; that will be a very materialistic solution. Quantity means matter. Equal amounts of both will give you only an appearance of synthesis but not a real synthesis -- a dead synthesis, not alive, not breathing, not with a heart beating. The real synthesis is a dialogue: not equal amounts of both, but a loving relationship, an I/thou relationship. It is a question of bridging the opposites, not putting them together in one place. Both are important, immensely important. Neither analysis can be discarded nor intuition. Discard analysis and you become outwardly poor, starved, unhealthy. And when one is outwardly poor, starved, unhealthy, how can he go inwards? It is impossible. The outward poverty prevents the inward journey. You are so obsessed with food, clothes,…
Read the full discourse →
Nirvana The Last Nightmare · Discourse 6
1976-02-16 · Buddha Hall · English

Osho, what will happen if the eastern mind meets with the western mind?

The officer-in-charge took pity on him and he said, 'I can understand your difficulty, but now only one thing can be done. That too is not regular, but for you I will make a concession. You can choose either the indian hell or the german hell.' 'But what is the difference?' the man asked. 'In the german hell,' explained the officer-in-charge, 'you spend half your time eating all the food you want, listening to music and disporting yourself with girls. in the other half of the time you are pinioned to the wall and beaten mercilessly. Your nails and teeth are pulled out and boiling oil is poured over you.' 'And in the indian hell?' 'In the indian hell you spend half your time eating all the food you want, listening to music and disporting yourself with girls. In the other half of the time you are pinioned to the…
Read the full discourse →
And now the East is turning Western and the West is turning Eastern. In the East the attraction is for Western technology, Western science, Western rationalism. Einstein, Aristotle, and Russell have taken hold of the Eastern mind, while in the West quite the opposite is happening: Buddha, zen and yoga have become more significant. This is a miracle. The East is turning communist, Marxist, materialist, and the West is beginning to think in terms of expanding consciousness -- meditation, spirituality, ecstasy. The wheel can turn and we can change our burdens. It will be illuminating for a moment, but then the whole nonsense will begin again. The East has failed in one way and the West has failed in another way, because they both tried denying one part of the mind. You have to transcend both parts and not be concerned with one while denying the other.
Read the full discourse →
Geeta Darshan · Vol 17 · Discourse 8
Hindi · English translation

Osho, you said that the Hindu genius was once supremely intelligent and succeeded in touching the ultimate heights of religion. As a result there came into being devas, dvijas, gurus and gnanis; the Upanishads, the Gita, the Dhammapada and the Jina-vani. Then what is the reason that the same people have fallen into the great abyss of decline for a thousand years, with no sign of rising?

The West too produces, once in a while, an Einstein—knower of the outer. But even that does not solve anything. The masses remain full of tension and anxiety. Is it not possible to accept the outer and the inner together? Both are; your acceptance or rejection makes no difference—only you get into trouble. Take breathing: it goes out and it comes in. If you insist, “I will only draw it in; I will not let it go out,” you will die. Another insists, “I will not let it go in; I will hold it out here”—he too will die. The East died; the West died—because both embraced only half. I call courageous the one who accepts both together, who says, “I will keep both pans of the scale in balance.” The East has lost; the West has lost. And the danger is: when you lose one thing, a craving arises…
Read the full discourse →
Keep Exploring

Related Questions on Mind