According to Osho, Sartre’s response is ‘very much Zen-like’ because he has earned an authentic no—the vital negation—yet he stops there; Zen demands moving from no to yes and then beyond both into a naked, seedless clarity without any stance. Thus Sartre stands on the threshold Buddha crossed: near transcendence, but fixed at the border of nihilistic negation.
He’s close to wisdom by saying “no,” but real Zen goes past both “no” and “yes” into a clear mind that clings to nothing.
From the Discourses
Passages where Osho speaks to this question — each links to the complete discourse.
Yoga The Alpha And The Omega Vol 7 · Discourse 8
1976-01-08 · Buddha Hall · English
Question: OSHO, ONCE YOU REFERRED TO SARTRE SAYING THAT WHEN HE WAS ASKED IN AN INTERVIEW. "WHAT IS THE MOST SIGNIFICANT THING IN YOUR LIFE?" SARTRE REPLIED EVERYTHING. TO LOVE TO LIVE, TO SMOKE. AND THEN YOU REMARKED THAT THIS REPLY IS VERY ZEN-LIKE. BUT DOES SARTRE HAVE A ZEN-CONSCIOUSNESS? To live the no is to sacrifice oneself at the altar of negativity, to suffer tremendously, to move in the world of desperation, to move in the darkness, to move in the hopeless state of mind where darkness prevails ultimately, endlessly, and there is no hope for any morning -- to move into the meaningless and to not in any way create any illusion; because the temptation is great.Read the full discourse →
The Sun Rises In The Evening · Discourse 5
1978-06-15 · Buddha Hall · English
Question: THE MOON REFLECTED IN THE STREAM, THE WIND BLOWING THROUGH THE PINES IN THE COOL OF THE EVENING, IN THE DEEP MIDNIGHT, -- WHAT IS IT FOR? WHEN WE ATTAIN REALITY, IT IS SEEN TO BE NEITHER PERSONAL NOR IMPERSONAL. THERE IS NO SIN, NO PARADISE, NO LOSS OR GAIN; ABOUT THIS TRANSCENDENTALITY, NO QUESTIONS! WHO IS THOUGHTLESS? WHO IS BIRTHLESS? The question of meaning is the most ancient question, and meaning has not been found. Many answers have been given, many philosophies propounded, but they are all consolatory; they give you consolation. Yes, you can deceive yourself for a time, but if you are intelligent enough, you always come to see the futility of it all. If you are intelligent enough, those consolations won't help.Read the full discourse →
God Is Dead Now Zen Is The Only Living Truth · Discourse 1
1989-02-06 · Gautam the Buddha Auditorium · English
Question: OUR BELOVED MASTER, ON THEIR FIRST MEETING, SEIGEN ASKED SEKITO, "WHERE DO YOU COME FROM?" AND SEKITO REPLIED, "I COME FROM SOKEI." SEIGEN HELD UP A WHISK AND SAID, "DID YOU FIND THIS OVER THERE?" SEKITO REPLIED, "NO, NOT ONLY WAS IT NOT OVER THERE, BUT IT WAS ALSO NOT IN THE WEST LAND." SEIGEN ASKED, "YOU REACHED THE WEST LAND, DIDN'T YOU?" TO WHICH SEKITO REPLIED, "IF I HAD REACHED, I COULD HAVE FOUND IT." SEIGEN SAID, "NOT YET ENOUGH -- SPEAK FURTHER." SEKITO REPLIED, "YOU SHOULD ALSO SPEAK FROM YOUR SIDE. HOW IS IT YOU URGE ONLY ME?" SEIGEN SAID, "THERE'S NO PROBLEM FOR ME IN ANSWERING YOU, BUT NOBODY WOULD AGREE WITH IT." SEIGEN CONTINUED, "WHEN YOU WERE AT SOKEI, WHAT DID YOU GET THERE?" SEKITO REPLIED, "EVEN BEFORE GOING TO SOKEI, I HADN'T LOST A THING.Read the full discourse →
The Secret Of Secrets Vol 1 · Discourse 10
1978-08-20 · Buddha Hall · English
Question: OSHO, ALL MY LIFE I HAVE SAID YES AND NOW THAT I AM HERE WITH YOU AND THE YES SEEMS REALLY RIGHT, THERE COMES ONLY NO. WHAT IS THIS NO? Sri Aurobindo was asked by a philosopher, 'Do you believe in God?' and he said, 'No.' The philosopher was, for a moment, shocked. He had come a long way, believing that this man had come to know God, and this man says, 'I don't believe in God. For a moment he could not gather courage to ask anything else. Shocked, he was dumb. Then he said, 'But I thought that you had seen God.' Sri Aurobindo laughed and said, 'Yes, I have seen, that's why I say I don't believe. Belief is out of ignorance. I know! I don't "believe".' And remember it: you have to know, you are not here to believe.Read the full discourse →
The Cypress In The Courtyard · Discourse 2
1976-06-05 · Chuang Tzu Auditorium · English
Once you can remain in your body, but unconnected with it, meditation has happened. This is the first satori. Many hours may pass but you will not feel the passage of time. But this happens only when fear has disappeared and your mind has become acclimatised to the new experience and it is not too terrified by it but becomes curious. Your mind will become so interested that it wants to know more about it and the fear will become transformed into a witnessing of what has happened. Go into it more and more, little by little, and if you start feeling that you will go mad, absorb that madness also by and by. Many people have gone mad. If they are working without a master and not knowing what to do, they land themselves in something which they cannot manage, and they can go mad.Read the full discourse →